9 August 2026
This past week, I had drinks with friends, and somehow my departure from organized religion came up. We bonded over being forced to watch Left Behind at much too young of an age, and agreed that evangelicals are abusing children.
My friends were churchy-churches as kids, as many of us were, but are not so much any more, as most of us. Christopher Durang put it best: "I know many children who are Catholic. I don't know any Catholic adults." This is not a direct quote, as I was sure it was from Sister Mary Ignatius Explains It All For You, but I don't have the play. The point is that it fits my thoughts thematically, as few of us adults are still churchgoers. For a good reason.
And we all have a story.
And mine is coming, you've been warned.
First: Not Catholic. I honestly would not have been able to handle church as a child if we were Catholic. Who can sit still that long with so much pagentry and smoke?
We attended Berean Fundamental Church in Lakewood. It's on Jewell and for a minute was the River Of Life Church, but now the marqee is in Spanish. I think. I don't speak Spanish, but it looks Spanish.
I attended that church until I was 12 or 13 (unsure which year). I was tasked with relentlessly inviting other kids to attend Wednesday nights, making me quite popular at school. Kids were constantly begging to be invited to attend church on a Wednesday night. It was relentless, I almost needed a bodyguard.
NARF!
In case you missed the sarcasm, I was treated like a borderline pariah.
I went to Sunday School on Sunday morning, regular church on Sunday night and AWANA on Wednesdays. There were Saturday things I have a vague recollection of doing, and I think my dad helped mow the church lawn.
When kids would ask what kind of church I was aggressively pushing on them, I had no answer. My mom said we were "a bounce off of Baptist". But that seems incorrect, as the word "fundamental" was part of the name, but fundamental to what? If I look it up today, it's Fundamental Baptist...but I do not remember that word on the church sign. Maybe it was?
Ok, went down a google rabbit hole...we were just Berean Fundamental and apparently they still have a summer camp in Lakewood. Eww.
There were rules we did not follow because I guess we didn't want to. I have no idea why we didn't just go to another church. But my parents said church doctrine stated that we weren't supposed to attend movies, play cards, listen to rock music or dance.
We went to the movies. Mom played Gin Rummy with friends. I liked music. My sisters and I danced like fiends to our records and the radio, largely in front of the box fan. For effect. You know. As one does.
I imagine my mother saw us as the Partridge Family of the church. She stitched us matching outfits for the holidays, all reflecting her obsession with pioneers and bonnets--my God that woman loved Little House on the Prairie-- and we sang weekly. Mom played the guitar, and her three little well behaved girls would sing with her. We were very compliant. Mom also ran the games on Wednesday night for AWANA.
I even attended the Pastor's Vacation Bible school at his house after I had outgrown it, because my mom said he needed the support. I would argue I attended that church most of my congnizant life until the age of 13.
I attended Maranatha Bible Camp for a few summers. Enough that I started spouting that my career dream was to be a Maranatha Bible Camp Counselor. One year, counselors introduced me to Christian Rock. Not like Stryper-they were way later, and it was before Amy Grant and even softer than her. Literally, like soft do wop. I just looked up the album Andrus, Blackwood &Co,Following You, 1978.
So. The song "Jesus, You're So Wonderful" was the trigger.
I loved it. Mom loved it. Mom learned to play it on the guitar---it's a piano do wop and mom doesn't play piano. So. I assume Rockley's didn't have the sheet music, seems like it would have been a bit obscure. Maybe they did. Or maybe mom just listened to the album and figured it out. I seem to rememer sheet music, though. Whatever. Not relevent.
I sang it on Sunday morning. I was so excited. I sang it so well. I was a young belt with no idea what a belt was. It felt so good! I sounded so good!
There were a few smiles in the congregation, and maybe a sway or two. The audience had enjoyed it, but something was wrong. I was being...judged. It was different than previous performances, where I was judged with smiles and joy. This was very different. Their eyes were cold. Some looked sad. I was a kid, all I knew was it was not the usual reception.
By the evening service, we were iced out. Nobody would talk to us. I assumed I was not as good of a vocalist as I thought. Everything inside of me crashed. I assumed it was my voice. It never occured to me that it could be the song. It was a song praising Jesus. It was a song by a christian rock band. It had to be the way I sang it.
By the following Sunday, the pastor's messages had changed to the question of whether or not rock and roll music was sacred.
The printed pamphlet referred to the "perverted album" of Aqua Lung.
I did not sing Jethro Tull. I sang a Christian rock band's song that celebrated Jesus, not a socially relevent comment on the state of homelessness.
What was going on?
I sill do not know. All I can tell you is that we left the church. We tried a Baptist church with a strong youth program that did not appeal to me, and mom did not like the music ministry.
I have not belonged to a "church" since.
Theatre is my church.
We can sing and dance, we respect history and all art and all people and we do not judge you for your beliefs, only your commitment to the show.
Nobody is as judgey as zealous white church people.
I hung out with one of the ...I guess he was like a "deacon"- right, he was A Big Deal...I hung out with his daughter. Praised as a jewel of Christian Values, she was.
She taught me how to shoplift.
And by "taught" I mean she showed me how she was shoplifting, but I couldn't do it. I tried. I lifted a lipstick at Walgreens that I hid in a drawer until we moved to Green Mountain and I threw it away. So Much Guilt.
But I was the sinner for belting a song praising Jesus.
I see you.
I'm good. I do not need your judgment.
And I'm smart enough to know you were dangerous, and I'm not the only one you abused. I'm grateful my parents were smart enough to leave, and not stay and boot lick to be allowed back into the fold. I love that, it taught me volumes about self respect and may have sowed the seeds that grew the mohawk.
I have no idea why that church changed its name, I assume the pastor left---he was not terribly young--and nobody wanted to keep it going. I'm not mad at the brick and mortar building. It's sill there and I appreciate they've held on as a church and haven't been bulldozed for apartments.
And I also do no belong to any church. I haven't since.
And I don't judge anyone who likes their church. Good for you, go to church.
Just stop judging me because I don't adhere to your beliefs.
I have good reason.
I see church as controlling; a demon wearing a blonde wig.
I'm not interested in hearing your side of how great your church is. You heard my side. You have two valid response choices: to say "I'm sorry that happened" or "Me too".
"My church is nothing like that," is not a valid response. It's a defense.
Scene.